Anthracite League

Anthracite League

The league was founded by James H. Gildea, Coaldale's manager. On August 28, 1924, Gildea set up a meeting at the town hall in Coaldale to establish the league. The managers and owners of every major coal region team and the local sportswriters were all invited.


The Anthracite League, also referred to as the Anthracite Association, was a 1924 football league comprising teams based in eastern Pennsylvania. These teams were based in coal mining towns, hence the league name's reference to anthracite coal. The league lasted for just one season, before folding. The teams in the league were the Coaldale Big Green, Wilkes-Barre Barons, Shenandoah Yellow Jackets, the Gilberton Cadamounts, and the Pottsville Maroons.


In the years following World War I, the coal mining towns of eastern Pennsylvania produced a number of outstanding football clubs. An annual competition between the locals for the Curran Cup produced a game that was arguably the equal of that played by the fledgling National Football League. Although the these teams played each other as independents the success of the NFL eventually helped to prompt these teams to form their own official league.

Reasons for a league

The league was founded by James H. Gildea, Coaldale's manager. On August 28, 1924, Gildea set up a meeting at the town hall in Coaldale to establish the league. The managers and owners of every major coal region team and the local sportswriters were all invited.

The main reason for the league was to first put an end to teams raiding their opponents' rosters for big-name players. During this, money was being handed over by several managers in record amounts, as they hoped to lure the finest talent available. When the on-field talent wasn't available for signing, these managers would then steal players from other teams with the offer of higher salaries. As a result of the meeting, the teams agreed that the league teams had to secure all of their players prior to the start of the league season. A required list of eligible players had to also be filed by each team for all the others to observe. The plan was that all teams would be required to finish the season with the same players listed on the roster at the start of the year. Also a monetary forfeit of $500 or $1,000 had to be posted by each team to guarantee that the team would stick to its preseason player roster during league play and that there was no objection to any player being signed.

The second reason for establishing a league was to allow for the development of a concise scheduling format for the teams in the region. In the early 1920s, finding open dates when teams could play each other was difficult. Games were often delayed until the latest possible moment, usually 2–3 days before game day. One reason for this was the inability of some clubs to draw enough people into the ballpark. Many of the teams spent a lot of money signing talented players and in order to play them, the managers and owners relied heavily of the number of people in attendance for both home and road games. Every manager knew the importance and longed for the benefits of a sound, opponent-by-opponent schedule. As a result of the meeting, a schedule was agreed upon of twelve set dates from the beginning of October until the end of November. This move was also designed to allow non-league contests of natural rivals from nearby towns to take place at different intervals during and after the league's scheduled games.

With these two issues addressed, the Anthracite League was formed.

Broken agreement

The agreement from that meeting was soon broken by the Pottsville Maroons when Gus Sonnenberg, a guard from Dartmouth College and member of the Columbus Panhandles of the National Football League during the 1923 season, was signed by Maroons the day after a game in Coaldale. The Maroons were planning to stockpile as much talent as they could in an effort to provide the Maroons fans with a winning team. In doing so, the team's list of hired ringers topped that of any other club in region. In less than a week, several other league teams followed Pottsville's lead and signed every available big-name player, local or otherwise. Gilberton, acquired three new star players just days before their season opener. With the signings of Ben Shaw, Cecil Grigg, and Lou Smyth, all formerly of the NFL's Canton Bulldogs. The agreement to unify the coal region teams with an eligible player list took a backseat to the individual teams' "win at all cost" attitude.

This development promoted Gildea to schedule a league meeting on September 18, 1924 in Pottsville. At the meeting Gildea tried to push the understanding of an eligible player list, but to no avail. On September 25, 1924. in Shenandoah, a second meeting was called to address player eligibility. In this meeting Gildea made known his wished for the teams in the region to thrive off of their own local talent. However the four other teams felt since this was professional football, an eligible player list was a non-issue. The teams further contended that if an eligible list is made and the club must be held to that, then the players get the upper hand on the management and can demand almost any price for a game. Gildea was unable to make the other managers of the AFL agree with his ideas, as a result Coaldale team quit the newly formed league. However Gildea stated that the team would still abide by the league schedule which was earlier arranged with all of the region teams.

Renovated stadiums

Several teams in the Anthracite Football League made structural improvements to their stadiums before the season began. These improvements were made because most of the managers believed that their teams were worthy of the status of a major professional football league. Coaldale constructed a grandstand which could accommodate 8,000 fans. The cost of their projects cost an estimated $3,500. The total cost of the upgrades for all the teams in the league was estimated to be a then-astronomical $15,000.

The 1924 season

The Maroons and Coaldale began their opening days with wins against non-league opponents. However the Green Machine left the league after that win. Pottsville soon became the dominant force in the league and won the 1924 league championship with a 12-1-1 record. Giberton, which was led by future Pro Football Hall of Famer Fritz Pollard, finished second in the standings.

Folding the league

The league folded immediately after the season. The Maroons soon went on to be members of the NFL and were shortly the centerpoint of the 1925 NFL Championship controversy before moving to Boston in 1928 to become the Boston Bulldogs. The Bulldogs franchise then folded during the 1929 season.

Coaldale fell on hard times after they left the league. The team only won four games in 1924. Around the midpoint mark of their 1925 season they became strictly a traveling team, because every football fan in the region joined the Maroons' fanbase when the team joined the NFL. The team then joined the short lived Eastern League of Professional Football during its one season in 1926.

Only one of the Wilkes-Barre Barons league games was recorded in the AFL standings. That game was a 34-0 loss to the Maroons. This leaves the issue of the team's remaining league games a mystery. Some historians speculate that Wilkes-Barre attempted to imitate Coaldale's decision and quit the league However some theories say that the team disbanded, or that they just rescheduled most of their games to take advantage of their closer regional opponents. Wilkes-Barre's roster may have also been depleted by the other Anthracite teams.[1]

1924 standings

This table is shows both league and non-league game results.

The Pottsville Maroons were named the 1924 Anthracite League Champions.

Team Games Wins Losses Ties

Pottsville Maroons* 14 12 1 1

Gilberton Cadamounts 13 4 3 1

Shenandoah Yellow Jackets 8 4 4 0

Coaldale Big Green 10 4 6 0

Wilkes-Barre Barons 1 0 1 0



1922 – 9 Wins, 1 Loss, 2 Ties


9/17/1922 Marion Heights 37 0 W

9/24/1922 Bethlehem Saucona A.A. 60 0 W

10/08/1922 Bethlehem Thomas A.C. 12 0 W

10/15/1922 Atlantic City Roses 12 6 W

10/22/1922 New York Collegians 47 0 W

10/29/1922 East Falls 31 0 W

11/04/1922 Frankford Yellowjackets 0 14 L

11/12/1922 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 6 3 W

11/19/1922 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 6 6 T

11/26/1922 Pottsville Maroons 14 3 W

11/30/1922 Gilberton Catamounts 0 0 T

12/10/1922 Pottsville Maroons 14 0 W

239 32


1923 – 10 Wins, 4 Losses


9/23/1923 Avoca Buffaloes 7 3 W

9/30/1923 Lancaster (PA) 32 0 W

10/05/1923 Reading Gold Seal Pros 36 0 W

10/07/1923 Hazelton 22 0 W

10/14/1923 Chester 42 0 W

10/21/1923 Pottsville Maroons 10 7 W

10/28/1923 Mount Carmel 6 0 W

11/03/1923 Frankford Yellowjackets 0 20 L

11/11/1923 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 0 6 L

11/18/1923 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 3 0 W

11/25/1923 Pottsville Maroons 3 0 W

11/29/1923 Gilberton Catamounts 3 0 W

12/02/1923 Akron Pros 0 3 L

12/09/1923 Gilberton Catamounts 0 7 L

164 46


1924 – 4 Wins, 7 Losses


9/21/1924 All-Lancaster 42 0 W

9/28/1924 Bethlehem Thomas A.C. 13 0 W

10/05/1924 Conshohocken 52 0 W

10/19/1924 Pottsville Maroons 7 10 L

10/29/1924 Gilberton 3 9 L

11/01/1924 Millville F.C. 10 0 W

11/02/1924 Atlantic City Roses 0 7 L

11/09/1924 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 0 15 L

11/16/1924 Shenandoah Yellowjackets 0 6 L

11/23/1924 Pottsville Maroons 0 3 L

11/27/1924 Gilberton 0 17 L

127 67


1926 (EFL) – 7 Wins, 2 Losses, 3 Ties


9/26/1926 Bethlehem Bears 16 0 W

10/03/1926 Newark Blues 3 0 W

10/10/1926 Mount Airy 16 7 W

10/17/1926 Chester 16 0 W

10/29/1926 Atlantic City Roses 18 0 W

11/01/1926 Mount Carmel Wolverines 0 7 L

11/07/1926 All-Lancaster Roses 7 7 T

11/11/1926 Gilberton Catamounts 6 3 W

11/14/1926 Shenandoah Red Jackets 0 3 L

11/21/1926 All-Lancaster Roses 0 0 T

11/25/1926 Gilberton Catamounts 0 0 T

11/27/1926 Conshohocken A.A. 13 0 W

95 27